| Anthony T. Machi | (1978-80) |
| Paul F. Iannelli | (1980-82 & 1990-91) |
| Sam Purpero | (1982-83) deceased |
| Sam Ceraso | (1983-84) deceased |
| Anthony Cusatis | (1984-85) deceased |
| James Spataro | (1985-86) |
| Henry G. Piano, Esq. | (1986-87 & Feb. 2008 – Oct. 2010) |
| Phillip Purpero | (1987-88) deceased |
| Joseph Panella | (1988-89) |
| Betty Puccio | (1989-90) |
| Edward F. Leone, D.D.S. | (1991-92) deceased |
| George Menos | (1992-93) |
| Dominic H. Frinzi | (1993-94, 1995-97, 2001-03, Nov. 2006-Jan. 2008) deceased |
| William A. Jennaro | (1994-95) |
| Thomas G. Nardelli | (1997-99) |
| Joe Campagna, Jr. | (1999-2001) |
| Mario A. Carini | (2003-2005) deceased |
| Michael Palmisano | (2005-2006) |
| Dave Spano | (2010 – 2012) |
| Gina Spang | (2012 – 2014) |
| Giuseppe Vella | (2014 – 2016) |
| Dean Cannestra | (2016 – 2018) |
| Joseph Emanuele | (2018 – 2021) |
